Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Procedure Committee reviews “humble Address” procedure to demand papers
The Procedure Committee is today publishing recommendations on how the House of Commons should use its power to call for papers.
The purpose of the procedure
This power enables MPs to formally require documents and information to be produced by Government departments to assist the House in carrying out its duties.
The procedure is routinely used by Ministers to have reports of high profile public inquiries placed in the public domain without the risk of legal challenge. During the present Session it has also been used by the Opposition as a means of forcing the Government to divide the House on Opposition motions demanding papers—so-called ‘humble Address’ motions.
Scope of the inquiry
The Committee’s inquiry looked at concerns raised by Ministers and others over the use of the powers on Opposition days, and in particular the use of the procedure to compel the Attorney General to release his legal advice to the Government on the provisions of the Withdrawal Agreement between the UK and the EU.
As part of the inquiry the Committee took evidence from a number of senior serving and former MPs, including the Leader of the House, the Attorney General and Shadow Solicitor General and a former Attorney General, and looked at a number of issues arising from the House’s recent practice.
One issue looked at by MPs was the Law Officers’ convention, whereby the existence and content of advice to Government from the Law Officers is not to be disclosed outside the Government without the authorisation of the Attorney General.
The Committee recognises the importance of this convention, but does not recommend that the House should place any further prior restraint on the exercise of its power to call for papers. Similarly, the Committee does not recommend that the House should modify its practice so as to rule out motions calling for certain categories of information which the Government would not normally disclose.
Today’s report notes that motions seeking the production of papers may be defeated in the usual way by a Government using its majority in the Commons. Such motions may also be amended to require extracts of information to be provided.
The Committee recognises that where the House has demanded that information should be provided to a select committee, the committee has worked constructively with the Government to agree on the publication of information. It recommends that where a proposal is made to provide information to a select committee, the consent of the committee is secured in advance of the motion being debated.
The Committee concludes that the House does not require a change in its practices in order to accommodate the recent use of motions for return. It observes that the issues which have arisen are political ones which stem from disagreement between the Government and the Opposition over the terms of engagement on Opposition days: it is not clear that these underlying issues can be addressed simply by changes in the procedures and practices of the House.
Charles Walker OBE MP, Chairman of the Committee, said:
“The power to call for papers is crucial to the work of the House of Commons in scrutinising Government. The Committee recognised that Ministers have duties to keep certain information confidential in the national interest. But the Committee was not persuaded that it was right to curtail the powers of the House in order to observe conventions and obligations on the release of information which are operated solely by Ministers.
“The underlying issue is a disagreement between the Government and the Opposition about how both sides engage on Opposition days. The Committee did not think it was wise to make permanent procedural changes in response to a temporary political impasse.
“The House and the Government both recognise that motions calling for papers, if passed, are binding on Ministers. It is the House’s responsibility to use these powers in a proportionate way.”
Latest News from
Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Unfocused UK science and technology strategy risks “science superpower” becoming an empty slogan05/08/2022 11:38:00
The Committee’s report on a UK science and technology strategy concludes that there is an urgent need to develop an implementation plan for the Government’s welcome science and technology ambitions, or they risk becoming empty slogans.
Adult Social Care needs immediate funding injection and long-term plan, says Levelling Up Committee04/08/2022 15:33:00
The Government urgently needs to come forward with additional funding this year to help the ravaged adult social care sector meet immediate pressures, including inflation and unmet care needs, says the cross-party Levelling Up, Housing and Communities (LUHC) Committee in a report published today.
MPs question Government inaction on 'cruel' legislation targeting certain dog breeds04/08/2022 11:38:00
Members of the Commons Petitions Committee have expressed disappointment after Ministers at the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (DEFRA) responded to concerns about breed specific legislation by defending current practice and refusing to engage with petitioners.
EAC calls for rapid implementation of environmental principles in policymaking across Government29/07/2022 15:33:00
The Environmental Audit Committee (EAC) yesterday argued that there is no reason for any further delay to the roll-out of the Government’s Environmental Principles, which are intended to be binding on policymakers across many areas of central government.
New Report: MPs call for new Menopause Ambassador to keep women in the workplace29/07/2022 11:38:00
Employers' lack of support for menopausal symptoms is pushing 'highly skilled and experienced' women out of work, with knock-on effects on the gender pay gap, pension gap and the number of women in senior leadership positions.
Act now to prepare our nation’s defences28/07/2022 15:33:00
Today, the Defence Committee publishes its report “The Integrated Review, Defence in a Competitive Age and the Defence and Security Industrial Strategy”.
Pause deductions from benefits to ease cost of living crisis, MPs say28/07/2022 13:33:00
Automatic repayments to the Government and others owed by people claiming benefits should be put on hold to help households struggling with huge financial pressures during the cost of living crisis.
Transport Committee: Government must revisit decisions on Integrated Rail Plan28/07/2022 11:38:00
A thorough reassessment of the Government’s Integrated Rail Plan is essential to ensure this once-in-a-generation investment in rail is not a missed opportunity to address regional imbalances, urges the Transport Committee.