Windrush applicant left ‘worthless, broken, with no hope or prospects’
Ombudsman finds failings at UK Visas and Immigration (UKVI) as Windrush claimant waited over a year before getting a decision.
Mr R applied to remain in the UK via the Windrush Scheme in May 2018. Mr R had his own house and was a qualified tradesman. Since 2014, he has lost everything, being unable to provide documents which prove he has lived in the UK since before 1973. Mr R told the Ombudsman he feels worthless, broken and with no hope or prospects.
Waited over a year for application to be refused
Later in May 2018, Mr R had an appointment with UKVI, who told him it would take six weeks to get a decision. In fact, he waited over a year and did not receive a decision until August 2019. His application was refused.
UKVI stated that this was because it was unable to find any Home Office records to confirm Mr R had entered the UK before 1 January 1973. It accepted Mr R had been continuously resident in the UK since 1986, but said there was no record of him having settled status, or of having been resident before that date.
The Ombudsman's investigation
The Ombudsman investigated the case after Mr R made a complaint. We found that the Windrush Taskforce had gathered all relevant evidence by September 2018. At that stage it proposed to refuse his application and advise him of next steps.
The Ombudsman found no reason for the subsequent 10-month delay, during which time Mr R was destitute and had no other way to resolve his immigration status. Had UKVI responded in a timely manner, Mr R would have been able to appeal the decision earlier or seek to settle his immigration status another way.
The Ombudsman also found that UKVI gave incorrect advice to Mr R when they told him that he would be able to claim benefits while waiting for their decision. Mr R was unable to prove his immigration status and had not previously been claiming benefits, so this was not the case. The Ombudsman found that UKVI should have been aware of Mr R’s eligibility. Their misleading advice gave him false hope at a time of immense financial and mental stress.
Rob Behrens, Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman, yesterday said:
"A person who has lived in the UK for decades has been treated with indifference by his own Government - a shocking example of what happens when we fail to recognise the dignity of all members of our society.
"We encourage anyone who has complained about their treatment under the Windrush Scheme to come to us via their local MP if they are not happy with the response they have received.”
Mr R’s MP, Shadow Secretary of State for International Trade Emily Thornberry, yesterday said:
"It is appalling that this man, who was particularly vulnerable, remained homeless for more than a year due to disgraceful delays on the part of the Home Office. The hostile environment has caused enormous hardship, and the Windrush scheme has let so many people down – the Home Office should be ashamed of themselves.
"It is encouraging that the Ombudsman is recommending not only compensation for Mr R, but better communication and avoidance of delays to help all those affected by Home Office failings."
Recommendations to put things right
The Ombudsman has made recommendations to UKVI which include compensation to reflect the material and emotional distress caused to Mr R, as well as a full apology.
The Ombudsman has also made a range of systemic recommendations to help UKVI improve its openness and accountability in communicating with the people who come to it for help.
Latest News from
Draft Public Service Ombudsman Bill laid in Parliament05/12/2016 12:37:21
A new complaints body will provide the public with greater confidence that their voices have been heard.
Mother left with no respite or protection from disabled son by Somerset County Council20/01/2021 16:15:00
Three young children were left without any protection from their violent older brother after Somerset County Council failed to help their family, the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman has found.
Domestic abuse victim not supported properly by Wandsworth council when she became homeless15/01/2021 14:15:00
The Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman is highlighting the importance of councils considering the exceptional circumstances of people fleeing domestic abuse when assessing their housing needs, following a complaint about London Borough of Wandsworth.
Ombudsman comments on HSIB's patient safety learning report15/01/2021 08:05:00
Rob Behrens, Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman, yesterday commented on the Healthcare Safety Investigation Branch (HSIB) report Support for NHS staff following patient safety incidents.
Redbridge council left homeless family for too long in B&B14/01/2021 11:15:00
Two London schoolchildren were left in bed and breakfast accommodation for too long by Redbridge council, according to the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman.
Ombudsman annual report details further innovation in its service18/12/2020 12:43:00
The Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman has published its Annual Report and Accounts 2019-20, which details how it continued to be innovative in the way it improved its service and increased the value of its investigations.
London borough criticised for not saying sorry16/12/2020 12:43:00
London Borough of Harrow has been criticised by the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman for failing to properly remedy a complaint by apologising to a resident.
City council in foster carer dispute after girl’s mother dies11/12/2020 14:15:00
Birmingham City Council considered allowing an 11 year-old girl to be deported during a dispute with her foster carers, the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman has discovered.