IPPR responds to BBC review of impartiality in coverage of tax, spending and public debt
Carys Roberts, executive director of IPPR responds to the BBC’s review assessing whether due impartiality is being achieved across its coverage of taxation and public spending, and whether a breadth of voices and viewpoints are being reflected
“As the national broadcaster, the BBC’s role as a trusted news source is critical to the functioning of our democracy. It’s vital that the BBC is evidence-based and reflects well-informed debate in its coverage, and leads the way across the media sector.
“At times, it has fallen short of this ideal, in particular in how its reporters have discussed economic policy and government spending. That’s why in 2020 I joined other economists in challenging the BBC on its use of the ‘household analogy’ to describe public finances, and in its likening of government borrowing to a credit card. These metaphors are inaccurate, do not reflect current economic debate, and mislead the public, with an outsized impact on our politics.
“This authoritative review recognises that the BBC has, at times, fallen short of providing broad impartiality in its coverage of fiscal policy, and failed to reveal the political choices being made.
“The BBC’s upcoming action plan must prioritise a more diverse set of credible economic perspectives in its coverage, ensuring that those reporting on the issues have a good understanding of them, as well as considered use of language to describe and explain economic events. Only by doing so will the BBC be able to perform its function of aiding public understanding and holding politicians to account.”
NOTES TO EDITORS
- The BBC internal review was launched after 24 leading economists wrote to protest against the "inappropriate" use of household analogies during coverage of Chancellor's 2020 autumn spending statement, and more broadly across the BBC's news output. Carys Roberts was among its signatories.
- IPPR is the UK’s pre-eminent progressive think tank. With more than 40 staff in offices in London, Manchester, Newcastle and Edinburgh, IPPR is Britain’s only national think tank with a truly national presence. www.ippr.org
Latest News from
IFS - The context for the March 2024 Budget28/02/2024 16:20:00
How might the outlook for the public finances change and how should the Chancellor’s tax and spending plans change in response in the Budget?
IEA - A tax on e-cigarettes is a tax on smoking cessation28/02/2024 15:20:00
Christopher Snowdon, Head of Lifestyle Economics at the free market think tank, the Institute of Economic Affairs Comments on reports that the Chancellor is considering a tax on e-cigarette liquid in the upcoming budget
Adam Smith Institute Launches the Next Generation Centre28/02/2024 14:20:00
Leading UK think-tank will tonight launch a new policy initiative aimed at increasing economic opportunities for Britain’s young people
Clear vision needed for health and social care23/02/2024 16:25:00
The Scottish Government needs to develop a clear national strategy for health and social care to address the pressures on services.
The IFS Scottish Budget Report – 2024–2523/02/2024 10:20:00
This report looks at the key budgetary and public service issues for the Scottish Government for the 2024–25 financial year and beyond.
IEA - Red tape has fuelled the cost of living crisis, argues new IEA paper22/02/2024 16:20:00
Since 2000, sectors with heavy state intervention have experienced large price rises while competitive markets have experienced price falls.
IFS - Scottish Government boosts support for students’ living costs, but further cuts funding for universities to teach them22/02/2024 10:20:00
How much does the Scottish Government spend on higher education, and what challenges does it face on university funding and living cost support?
Demos - New statistics confirm that the pandemic has had a sustained negative impact on employment in the UK – here’s how policy makers should respond22/02/2024 09:20:00
This week the ONS published new statistics about employment and jobs in the UK – the first time for a number of months due to problems with survey response rates. With the appropriate caveats that the figures are estimates based on survey data – and therefore, as always, they come with a margin of error – here’s what we learnt from the new statistics, and some of the implications for policy makers.
IPPR - Calls for ‘quick win’ changes to social security as claimants say system leaves them ‘scared, exhausted and drained’21/02/2024 15:05:00
A state of the nation report on the UK’s social security system concludes with a package of reforms to cut poverty, incentivise work and deliver quick wins to create a modern welfare system.