Thursday 04 Jan 2024 @ 14:10
Chatham House
Printable version

US deterrence against Iran is damaged but not dead

EXPERT COMMENT

US politicians should not pretend that military strikes can alone solve the problem of Iran and its proxies.

Attacks in recent weeks by Yemen’s Houthis on ships passing through the Bab el-Mandeb strait have increased calls in Washington for a forceful US military response directed at Iranian proxies – and at Iran itself.

Officials in the Department of Defense as well as senior officers in the US military have expressed concern about what they view as a relatively timid US response to the Houthi attacks. 

This follows Sen. Tom Cotton’s proposal for ‘massive retaliation’ against Iranians operating in Iraq and Syria, and presidential candidate Tim Scott advocating ‘attacking Iran, not just warehouses in Syria’ during Republican debates.

It’s true that Iranian money, weapons and training have allowed the Houthis and other Tehran-supported militias in the region to launch sophisticated attacks against US personnel and interests in Iraq, Syria, the Red Sea, and elsewhere. 

But calls for a kinetic response against Iran imply that US deterrence is woefully inadequate. It seems more accurate to say it has been weakened, but not fatally.

Click here to continue reading the full version of this Expert Comment on the Chatham House website.

 

Channel website: https://www.chathamhouse.org/

Original article link: https://www.chathamhouse.org/2024/01/us-deterrence-against-iran-damaged-not-dead

Share this article
RESEARCH EXPERTS EVENTS MEMBERSHIP ACADEMY ABOUT

 

Latest News from
Chatham House

Beware the Middle East’s forgotten wars

21/05/2024 15:10:00

The international community neglected Israel–Palestine until violence exploded. They should not make the same mistake with the region’s other conflicts.

Washington should condition US aid to Israel – regardless of what happens in Rafah

16/05/2024 12:20:00

Refusing to hold Israel to the same standard as others undermines US objectives in the region and empowers others receiving military aid to act without fear of repercussions.

UK parties are pitching a 'pragmatic' foreign policy, but can a new government make the necessary hard choices?

15/05/2024 10:20:00

Labour and the Conservatives each place unusual emphasis on foreign policy in this election year. A new Chatham House paper advises what the next government must prioritize.

Egypt is holding its nerve over the Rafah operation. But its restraint shouldn’t be taken for granted

15/05/2024 09:20:00

Israel’s latest operation in Gaza has created two serious threats to Egypt’s government.

The UK should not rule out sending troops to Ukraine – despite Putin’s nuclear threats

14/05/2024 12:20:00

Backing down in the face of Russian threats is the worst option. The UK should join France in using strategic ambiguity.

Putin’s new term will show if the system he built can survive without him

14/05/2024 11:33:00

The next six years will show whether Putin is willing to allow technocrats outside his personal sphere to take over the system he created.

Vietnam’s political turmoil reveals a turn towards China – and away from the West

13/05/2024 12:20:00

Following a power struggle within the Communist Party of Vietnam, it is clearer than ever that its new hard-line leadership has no interest in confrontation with China or being part of an ‘anti-China’ coalition.

MOD data breach shows supply chain security continues to be a top priority

13/05/2024 11:33:00

Not for the first time, a Western government agency suffered a major data breach where third-party contractors were exploited as a likely weak link.

Xi Jinping hopes to improve EU–China relations – and drive a wedge between Europe and the US

10/05/2024 12:20:00

During his trip to Europe Xi could find it hard to address the damage wrought by COVID and Beijing’s stance on Ukraine. But he may exploit existing tensions with Washington.

Webinar Recording: Derby City Council AI Transformation Showcase Webinar