CDEI publish interim report on algorithmic bias in decision-making
techUK explores the recently published Centre for Data Ethics and Innovation interim report on algorithmic bias in decision-making.
The CDEI’s review focuses on exploring bias in four key sectors: policing, financial services, recruitment and local government. They have taken a phased approach to each sector, starting with policing and then moving onto financial services and recruitment, with work on local government starting in autumn 2019. Included in the interim report is a commitment from the CDEI to produce a briefing paper on Facial Recognition Technology (FRT) later in the autumn which will examine the wider ethical concerns surrounding the technology. This will not be limited to the use of FRT by the police.
The review seeks to answer three sets of questions:
- Data: Do organisations and regulators have access to the data they require to adequately identify and mitigate bias?
- Tools and techniques: What statistical and technical solutions are available now or will be required in future to identify and mitigate bias and which represent best practice?
- Governance: Who should be responsible for governing, auditing and assuring these algorithmic decision-making systems?
The interim report highlights that data itself is often the source of bias but, at the same time, it is a core element of tackling the issue. One issue raised is that some organisations are not collecting diversity information, due to nervousness of a perception that this data might be used in a biased way. This then limits the ability to properly assess whether a system is leading to biased outcomes. There is a tension between the need to create algorithms which are blind to protected characteristics while also checking for bias against those same characteristics.
Tools and techniques
CDEI’s early work suggests that new approaches to identifying and mitigating bias are required and that specific tools are already starting to be developed. However, there is limited understanding of the full range of tools and approaches available and what constitutes best practice. This makes it difficult for organisations that want to mitigate bias in their decision-making processes to know how to proceed and which tools and techniques they should use.
According to the review, there is currently limited guidance and a lack of consensus about how to balance significant trade-offs (for example between different kinds of fairness) or even how to have constructive and open conversations about them. In the policing sector, the CDEI are developing a Code of Practice in collaboration with the sector, to help to address this issue.
The report also highlights that a certain level of transparency about the performance of algorithms will be necessary for customers and citizens to be able to trust that they are fair. Giving developers of algorithms space and opportunity to test algorithms against standard datasets or to benchmark performance against industry standards may enable the development of a consensus about the appropriate definitions of fairness. The CDEI suggest that new functions and actors, such as third-party auditors, may also be required to independently verify claims made by organisations about how their algorithms operate.
The CDEI will submit a final report with recommendations to government in March 2020. If you’d like to find out more about this programme of work, please contact Katherine.
Latest News from
China's tech landscape25/01/2021 11:25:00
China is well on its way to achieving its goal of becoming a leading global technological superpower by 2050.
Understanding cybersecurity and data protection in China22/01/2021 16:25:00
Before a UK company sets up in China, it’s key to weigh up cybersecurity risks – for this, early research and expert advice are both vital.
Guest blog: The future of borders by Al Potter, Leidos22/01/2021 14:15:00
There are lessons to be learned from 2020. While the coronavirus pandemic impacted the flow of trade and travel, every effort has been made to ensure border transactions do not stop.
Skills for Jobs White Paper – what does it mean for the tech industry?22/01/2021 11:25:00
Government has ambitious plans to put the skills needs of businesses at the heart of the Further Education system.
Navigating business ethics in China21/01/2021 16:25:00
Why vigilance and transparency are key to operating successfully in the world’s second-largest economy.
Staying legal in China’s expanding markets21/01/2021 11:25:00
Get to know the red tape, but it doesn't need to stand in your way.
Secure video calls help all prisoners maintain essential family ties during pandemic20/01/2021 11:25:00
The Ministry of Justice (MoJ) recently, 18 January 2021, published an article explaining the roll out of video calling facilities to all prisons across England and Wales in just over 6 months.
Chinese business culture and market entry19/01/2021 16:25:00
To make the most of opportunities in China, you need to understand and address the risks.