CJEU: The UK can require recipients of child benefit & child tax credit to have a right to reside in the UK
The regulation on the coordination of social security systems lays down a series of common principles to be observed by the legislation of the Member States in that sphere so that the various national systems do not place at a disadvantage persons who exercise their right of freedom of movement and of residence within the EU. One of the common principles that the Member States must observe is the principle of equality. In the specific field of social security, the principle of equality takes the form of prohibiting any discrimination on grounds of nationality.
The Commission received numerous complaints from non-British EU citizens resident in the UK. They complained that the competent UK authorities had refused to grant them certain social benefits on the ground that they did not have a right to reside in the UK. Since the Commission took the view that the UK legislation does not comply with the regulation, it brought an action for failure to fulfil obligations against the UK. The Commission stated that under UK legislation it must be verified that persons claiming certain social benefits – including family benefits such as child benefit and child tax credit, which the present case concerns – are lawfully resident in the UK. According to the Commission, that condition is discriminatory and contrary to the spirit of the regulation since the regulation has regard only to the claimant’s habitual residence.
In response to those arguments, the UK, which relies on the judgment in Brey, 3 maintains that the host State may lawfully require that social benefits be granted only to Union citizens who fulfil the conditions for possessing a right to reside in its territory, conditions which are, essentially, laid down in an EU directive.4 Furthermore, while acknowledging that the conditions conferring entitlement to the social benefits at issue are more easily satisfied by its own nationals (as they have, by definition, a right of residence), the UK maintains that in each case the condition requiring a right of residence is a proportionate measure for ensuring that the benefits are paid to persons sufficiently integrated in the UK.
In today’s judgment, the Court dismisses the Commission’s action
Latest News from
EC steps up infringement against Hungary concerning its asylum law08/12/2017 16:30:00
The EC has decided to move forward on the infringement procedure against Hungary concerning its asylum legislation by sending a reasoned opinion.
It’s not the end of the world as we know it08/12/2017 16:15:00
Looking beyond the GDPR to imagine future scenarios for regulation of digital rights in the EU and around the world.
Agreement on EC proposal to tighten rules for safer & cleaner cars08/12/2017 15:30:00
The European Parliament, the Council and the EC reached a political agreement to significantly raise the quality level and independence of vehicle type-approval & testing, increase checks of cars that are already on the EU market and strengthen the overall system with European oversight.
Public consultation: draft guidance for identifying endocrine disruptors08/12/2017 15:15:00
EFSA and the European Chemicals Agency (ECHA) are inviting interested parties to comment on the draft guidance document for identifying endocrine disruptors under EU legislation for pesticides and biocides.
The EU needs a comprehensive food policy08/12/2017 14:30:00
A comprehensive food policy is urgently needed in order to improve coherence across food-related policy areas, restore the value of food and ensure the effective implementation of the UN Sustainable Development Goals, the EESC said at its plenary session on Wednesday.