Care Quality Commission
New supporting information for inspectors and Mental Health Act reviewers addresses the risk factors of closed environments
We're giving inspectors and their managers new supporting information about how to identify and respond to ‘closed cultures’ in services.
When a service has a closed culture, people are more at risk of abuse and human rights breaches. The supporting information includes risk factors and warning signs of closed cultures in health and social care settings and how inspectors and their managers should consider and respond to these.
Closed environments may develop in services where people are situated away from their communities, where people stay for months or years at a time, where there is weak management of these services and where staff often lack the right skills, training or experience to support people. We are paying particular attention to services that provide care for people with a learning disability and or autism, but the information relates to services in any sector.
Why are we releasing this now?
In May 2019, BBC Panorama exposed a culture of abuse and human rights breaches of people with a learning disability and autistic people at Whorlton Hall. It reinforced how everyone involved in the care of people with a learning disability or autistic people has a part to play in identifying where abuse and human rights breaches may be taking place.
Since then we have written to providers to highlight that we have taken steps to strengthen the way we assess these types of services. We asked that providers consider what steps they can take to better protect the human rights of people in their service.
There are particular challenges in regulating services where there is a culture of concealment of abuse and human rights breaches. This supporting information will help our frontline staff to assess services where there may be a risk of abuse and abusive cultures. It will also help managers in CQC to support their frontline staff in this difficult task.
What’s the purpose of the information for inspectors, Mental Health Act Reviewers and their managers?
- Helps inspectors and Mental Health Act Reviewers identify services where there may be a high inherent risk of a closed culture that might lead to abuse or breaches of human rights and lay outs how we should monitor these services
- Helps inspectors and Mental Health Act Reviewers identify warning signs that there may be a closed or punitive culture, or risk of such a culture developing and confirms that we will have a low threshold for carrying out an inspection where warning signs are developing in a service with a high inherent risk
- Sets out to inspectors and Mental Health Act reviewers how to use strengthened regulatory policy, methods and processes when there is a high inherent risk and/or warning signs. This includes gathering information from people who use services and their families early in the inspection planning, so their views can influence other evidence gathering, as well as a focus on inspection on the experience of people at the highest risk of human rights breaches.
What else will we be doing long-term?
We will be conducting a longer-term review of our methodology from a human rights perspective. We are committed to working closely with people who use services, families and professionals to develop this.
This will include implementing any recommendations from the independent reviews that we have conducted into our regulation of Whorlton Hall.
Download the supporting information
- Identifying and responding to closed cultures: Summary
- Identifying and responding to closed cultures: Supporting information for CQC staff
Latest News from
Care Quality Commission
The recovery challenges for NHS hospital services23/09/2021 11:05:00
This month’s Insight report looks at how NHS trusts are planning for people’s care while tackling a backlog of treatment caused by COVID-19.
Action to ensure all women receive safe, effective, and personalised maternity care must be prioritised to prevent future tragedies21/09/2021 13:05:00
A new report from the Care Quality Commission (CQC) highlights continued concern about the variation in the quality and safety of England’s maternity services - prompting the regulator to call for improvements to be prioritised to ensure safer care for all mothers and babies.
More people report a ‘very good’ overall experience of urgent and emergency care, but access to emotional support and timely pain relief both areas for improvement15/09/2021 15:20:00
Findings from a survey of more than 48,000 people who received urgent and emergency care in 2020 show an increase in the number who said their overall experience was ‘very good’. However, the results also reveal concerns among some about access to emotional support, pain management and the availability of staff when they needed help or attention.
CQC report highlights how the right community support can improve outcomes for people with a learning disability, a mental health need and autistic people08/09/2021 13:10:00
The Care Quality Commission’s Home for Good report published today celebrates examples of successful community support provided to people with complex needs.
Statement on COVID-19 vaccination of people working/deployed in care homes: the role of the Care Quality Commission04/08/2021 12:25:00
The Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) have amended the Health and Social Care Act 2008 (Regulated Activities) Regulations 2014 so that, from 11 November 2021, all care home workers, and anyone else entering a care home, will need to be fully vaccinated against COVID-19, unless they have an exemption.
CQC publishes response to consultation on flexible and responsive regulation23/07/2021 13:38:00
We yesterday published our response to a recent consultation on changes for more flexible and responsive regulation
Care Quality Commission publishes data showing death notifications involving COVID-19 received from individual care homes22/07/2021 15:05:00
The Care Quality Commission (CQC) has published data showing death notifications involving COVID-19 received from individual care homes between 10 April 2020 and 31 March 2021. This is accompanied by our CQC Insight report which draws from the data to make the key points and provides crucial context for understanding what this data says.
CQC publish provider collaboration reviews looking at cancer services and care for people with a learning disability22/07/2021 12:25:00
We have published 2 new reports as part of our series of provider collaboration reviews (PCRs).
Taking action to prevent infections and protect people from closed cultures21/07/2021 16:10:00
This month’s insight report reviews our inspections of infection prevention and control (IPC) in NHS trusts and highlights how we are identifying and responding to the risks of closed cultures. It also includes an article to accompany our publication of data on death notifications involving COVID-19 received from individual care homes.