Online Safety Bill 'not fit for purpose', say tech experts
Plans to compel social media platforms to tackle online harms are not fit for purpose according to a new poll of IT experts.
The Online Safety Bill would put a duty on tech giants like Facebook and Google to develop systems to identify and remove illegal material, as well as deal with content that is harmful to adults and children. Ofcom would enforce this as the regulator.
Only 14% of tech professionals believed the legislation was ‘fit for purpose’, according to the survey by BCS, The Chartered Institute for IT.
Some 46% said the bill was not workable, with the rest unsure.
Freedom of speech
The legislation would have a negative effect on freedom of speech, most IT specialists (58%) told BCS.
Only 19% felt the measures proposed would make the internet safer, with 51% saying the law would not make it safer to be online.
There were nearly 1,300 responses from tech professionals to the survey by BCS.
Legal but harmful content
The government has stressed the bill does not require removal of legal content; but larger platforms must set out how ‘priority content that is harmful to adults’ – such as suicide related material - is dealt with by their service.
This could include specifying that the content would be removed, or deprioritising it in news feeds or simply making it clear what content is freely accessible. Types of harmful content will be specified by parliament; platforms must also take steps not to limit freedom of speech.
Be part of something bigger, join the Chartered Institute for IT.
Just 9% of IT specialists polled said they were confident that ‘legal but harmful content’ could be effectively and proportionately removed.
Some 74% of tech specialists said they felt the bill would do nothing to stop the spread of disinformation and fake news.
Just one quarter (25%) felt it was realistic for Ofcom to ask platforms to ‘develop or source’ accurate technology to detect sexual abuse material; 57% said it was not.
The Online Safety Bill is now due to return to parliament after the new Prime Minister is chosen on 5 September.
Legislation needs ‘fundamental review’
Rob Deri, Chief Executive of BCS, The Chartered Institute for IT recently said:
“There is real need to prevent online harm, but this law only goes part way to trying to achieve that. The aim should be to prevent hatred and abusive online behaviours, by stopping harmful material appearing online in the first place – and that takes a mix of both technical and societal changes.
“A new Prime Minister should take the opportunity to fundamentally review the Online Safety Bill in its current form.
“The technology itself has an important part to play in keeping people safe on social media platforms. However, the Bill leans too heavily on tech solutions to prevent undesirable content, which can’t be relied upon to do that well enough, and could affect freedom of speech and privacy in ways that are unacceptable in a democratic society.
“The legislation should also focus on substantive programmes of digital education and advice, so that young people and their parents can confidently navigate the risks of social media throughout their lives.”
About the survey:
This report was generated on 02/08/2022. Overall, 1296 members of BCS, The Chartered Institute for IT completed the poll during the period 21/07 to 02/08 2022.
Latest News from
BCS joins national effort to boost small business digital adoption04/12/2023 14:10:00
BCS has joined the tech coalition behind Tech Hub, a major new national initiative designed to scale tech adoption and boost digital investment and skills amongst the UK’s small and mid-sized business (SMB) community.
Teach children AI from start of secondary school, professional body recommends30/11/2023 09:20:00
Schools should teach children how to use AI from the age of 11, according to the professional body for computing.
BCS partners with CWP to create a multimedia series showcasing the Digital Pioneers shaping our world09/11/2023 14:10:00
BCS is partnering with Content With Purpose (CWP) to produce a wide-ranging digital series exploring IT’s contribution to society; solving global challenges, driving innovation, transforming lives, and creating a future of possibilities.
Google DeepMind’s Demis Hassabis among the recipients of prestigious computing award - BCS Lovelace Medal 202308/11/2023 10:20:00
Demis Hassabis CBE, co-founder of AI research company Google DeepMind; computer scientist Professor Jane Hillston MBE; and leading digital policy expert, Professor Tom Crick MBE, will all receive the BCS Lovelace Medal this year.
PM should make ethics a priority at AI Safety Summit, say tech professionals28/09/2023 16:10:00
Rishi Sunak should put ethics high on the global agenda when the UK hosts the AI Safety Summit this autumn, according to research by the professional body for computing.
Online Safety Bill shouldn’t rely on technology to deliver child protection31/08/2023 14:10:00
The Online Safety Bill (OSB) should not rely on emerging technology solutions to deliver child protection without rigorous analysis of their flaws - according to a new paper published by the professional body for IT.
Computer Science fastest growing STEM subject25/08/2023 11:10:00
On results day, the professional body for computing, BCS, The Chartered Institute for IT, congratulates the 87,660 people awarded a GCSE in computer science, the fastest growing STEM subject.
Record numbers of women will start computing degrees this year, new figures show18/08/2023 14:10:00
More young women than ever before will start computing degrees this September, amid the rising profile of AI, according to figures released yesterday.