Competition & Markets Authority
|
|
Power, agency and good growth
A speech by Sarah Cardell, the CMA’s Chief Executive, delivered at the Chatham House Competition Policy Conference 2026.
Who has the power?
Good morning and thank you to Chatham House for inviting me to deliver this keynote for a third-year running. This event has become something of a landmark in the CMA diary – a valuable opportunity to step back and take stock of the work we are doing and why we do it.
With so much happening day to day, moments like this – to pause and reflect – feel increasingly rare. Demands on our time and attention only seem to grow; the world seems to move faster; markets fluctuate; geopolitics and military conflict create disruption and shocks. Technologies accelerate by the minute.
Uncertainty is increasingly baked into our everyday. And when that happens, we can sense the forces that push and pull against us more acutely. It is little wonder that too many people in the UK today express a growing feeling of powerlessness.
The reality is complex. We do have agency, of course, but our lives are moulded by the dynamics of economic power.
- who can choose and who can challenge
- who can shape or disrupt markets
- who is simply subject to the decisions of others
These dynamics exist every time a person buys a product or service; when a worker wants to move jobs; when an innovative young startup challenges an incumbent; or when the country makes decisions about its future.
Part of the CMA’s role is to understand where economic power sits, when it has become too concentrated, and how competition, consumer protection and altered market dynamics can help. That matters because the ability to make meaningful choices is fundamental to human dignity. It is also fundamental to being a sovereign nation.
Our concern is not only how much the economy grows, but whether people, businesses and places have agency within it and whether the benefits are tangible in every community. The CMA has a role to play in making that a reality.
So, the subject of my speech today is ‘power, agency and good growth.’ I am going to explore the layers of economic power - from the individual all the way up to the country at large - and what the CMA can do to strengthen agency, opportunity, prosperity and sovereignty for the UK.
The power of people: agency, choice and fair treatment
The most fundamental expression of economic power is the power we all have as individuals to make genuine choices in our everyday lives. That means both understanding what we are choosing based on clear and accurate information; and having the confidence we will be treated fairly. Without this, people feel understandably angry and frustrated, unable to exercise meaningful control over their lives.
No one likes that sense of being misled or ‘done to’ by companies. That’s why effective consumer protection is so important. It operates in part as a response to imbalances of information and power. It prevents people from being manipulated or undermined. It strengthens agency.
The Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act gives the CMA the ability to protect consumers from harm and give people real choices. Whether booking your teenage daughter’s first driving lesson (something I will have the pleasure of next year), deciding where to park, buying flights for a well-deserved holiday, a new washing machine, or a ticket to see your favourite band, you should be able to do so with confidence. No false countdown clocks pressuring you, no fake reviews misleading you, no hidden fees leaving you out of pocket.
These are everyday decisions, but they make a real difference to how people experience agency in their own lives. When people can choose how they live, and how they spend their money, free from manipulation, hidden costs and unfair practices, they feel more in control. That is an important part of how economic freedom is experienced day to day.
Those who follow the CMA’s work will have realised this was not a random list. These are all areas where we have already taken action under the new consumer regime, resulting in £2.3 million directly back in people’s pockets, and fines of nearly £12 million so far this year.
I want to be clear, though, that our approach to implementation has not been simply to penalise firms who break the law. It has also been to empower businesses through clear guidance and constructive engagement - even from before the regime launched. The vast majority of firms who treat their customers well should not be at a disadvantage to those who flagrantly ignore the rules. So, we are using our consumer protection powers to give agency to those businesses too, supporting them to do the right thing by their customers.
One area I particularly want to highlight in the context of consumer protection is the impact of agentic AI, which represents a transformational shift - from tools that help us make decisions to agents acting on our behalf. By helping people navigate increasingly complex markets, secure better deals and reduce time and effort, these technologies could make markets work better for millions of people. But we are also acutely alive to the risks.
In March this year we published research that explored how agentic AI could change what agency means for consumers. We talked about how, as people delegate more decisions, transparency, accountability and control become ever more important. There is much these technologies may be able to do for us. But the key question is whether they strengthen people’s agency or gradually diminish it. That is why the CMA’s focus is supporting responsible innovation and ensuring it protects people’s ability to make meaningful choices about their own lives.
We also published guidance for businesses seeking to roll out agentic AI, making it clear that existing consumer protection law applies and businesses remain responsible for the actions of the systems they deploy. Consumers must be given accurate information, their rights must be respected, and firms cannot use technology as an excuse to evade accountability.
Eight months on from these publications, we are at a critical juncture, as we anticipate the first wave of these services rolling out to UK consumers. We are actively engaging with the firms developing and deploying these technologies, to ensure they understand their responsibilities. At the same time, we are working closely with other regulators, and this is where the Digital Regulation Cooperation Forum really comes into its own, moving at pace to identify and act on emerging and overlapping risks. We are closely scrutinising the rollout of agentic products in the UK and will not hesitate to act to protect consumers where we have concerns.
Where powerlessness is most acute: essential services
A lack of agency in everyday transactions can be deeply frustrating. But when it comes to essential goods and services, powerlessness can have even more acute consequences. We saw this when hundreds of mostly rural households had their heating oil contracts cancelled after conflict broke out in the Middle East earlier this year. It underscored how vital effective consumer protection is when we are at our most vulnerable, impacted by forces beyond our control. It also reinforced findings from other areas of our work that where you live can determine the options and outcomes available to you in some of these essential services.
So, the second layer of power I want to explore is in essential services, where people are sometimes left without meaningful alternatives in areas affecting their health, security and the cost of living. The most effective way to provide these services is a pressing question for policymakers today, reflected in the debate about the merits of public and private control.
The CMA has long-standing and deep expertise in these markets, including previous studies into funerals, children’s social care and road fuel; and in our current work in the private dentistry and childcare markets. By examining how markets work, where power sits, and what incentives operate, we are ideally placed to analyse where unconstrained market dynamics have failed to deliver good outcomes for people, businesses and places.
Over the next 3 months we will be publishing updates across our road fuel, dentistry and childcare work and, in each case, our analysis of the drivers of poor outcomes will include a strong focus on regional and local disparities. By way of a quick preview:
In road fuel, we will build on our 2023 market study and subsequent statutory monitoring function, with a particular focus on what is driving persistent variation in localised pricing and how the recently launched Fuel Finder can be harnessed to kickstart more effective competition in that market.
And in dentistry, we are using our unique information gathering powers to carry out an in-depth study which, for the first time, explores the complex interaction of public and private provision of this essential service and provides an unprecedented spotlight on the variation in local and regional outcomes.
Our market study powers mean the CMA is well placed to identify the drivers of poor market outcomes, but the question of how those outcomes are improved can be more complex. In many cases we recommend measures to intensify competition or improve consumer protection. But for some essential services, these kinds of interventions may prove insufficient alone to reset market dynamics and deliver better outcomes. Depending on the problem, the answer may be sharper competition, more effective regulation, a redesign of incentives, or, in some cases, greater public control.
Indeed, I think the CMA’s studies in these areas can be seen as a trailblazer for the government’s wider endeavour to improve market outcomes through its 3 taskforces on Public Control, Cost of Living and Community Renewal - and the CMA is actively working to support government across all of these initiatives.
The power to challenge: firms, scale-ups and workers
So far, I have mostly touched on the demand side of economic power. On the supply side, the power of firms, scale-ups and workers to challenge matters too. An economy is far less dynamic when established firms can entrench their position unchecked, closing off opportunities for innovators, workers and entrepreneurs. When this happens, everybody loses. Tackling this power is really the core of the UK digital markets competition regime.
Take contactless payments, which now represent around 60% of all UK card payments. Chances are, if you own an Apple device, you are using an Apple digital wallet. The CMA has heard concerns from businesses who say Apple’s fees and access rules for its near field communication (the technology that enables contactless payments), make it too difficult for challengers to innovate and compete. Last month, we announced proposals that would require Apple to remove certain barriers to entry, helping create the conditions for brilliant UK businesses, including in our world class fintech sector, to develop new products and services here - from payment apps to travel passes and digital keys.
This is just one example of how we are using the digital markets regime to tackle substantial and entrenched market power. Another is search services, where we are requiring Google to give publishers meaningful control over how their content is used in its AI services; better data on how people engage with that content; and clear attribution when it appears in AI responses. These measures should give businesses greater power over how they reach customers, use their own content and negotiate with one of the world’s most powerful digital firms.
We want to see continued innovation and investment from the largest tech firms, whose products and services are used by millions of people and businesses in the UK. But we also want to ensure businesses have fair access to customers, and that innovative firms can compete on the merits of their ideas. Our approach is designed to be targeted, proportionate and participative, but there is a clear principle running through all our digital markets work: firms must not be able to use entrenched market power to close off opportunities for others to challenge, innovate and succeed.
This principle is by no means confined to digital markets. Research from the CMA’s Microeconomics Unit shows that high-growth firms are a small share of UK businesses, but make up a disproportionate contribution to employment, turnover, innovation and economic growth. It is crucial that UK scale-ups have a fair chance to win customers and grow, rather than facing prohibitive barriers to entry and success. When this fails, not only do we lose promising individual firms, but we also lose innovation, investment and the pressure to improve.
The same is true in an economy which hamstrings its workers. In a well-functioning labour market, people should feel empowered to change jobs, move to a different city, or set up their own venture. Our labour markets report in 2024 showed that where people are unable to move or choose, innovative firms may struggle to acquire workers from less productive ones, and the allocation of skills and knowledge can become frozen.
In that report, we found that the prevalence of non-compete clauses across the economy - including for lower-paid workers - could act as a barrier to switching jobs. They impede mobility, knowledge sharing and incentives for innovation. This has been reflected in government’s recently announced plans to legislate on these agreements, making sure they are no longer a barrier to hiring at startups and scaleups.
The power of the state: purchasing, shaping and coordinating markets
That brings me to our next layer of power: that of the state. Government is one of the most influential actors in the UK economy. How it uses that power can make an enormous difference.
One of the clearest examples is public procurement. Chatham House regulars may remember me emphasising this in last year’s speech, and it remains a focus for the CMA. Too often, procurement has been treated as an administrative function, when in fact it is one of the most powerful economic levers available to government. Through what it buys, how it buys, the certainty it gives suppliers, and the design of the processes by which it procures - through all of this the state has the power to help determine which firms grow, which technologies are adopted, how supply chains develop, where investment flows and where the country builds its strategic domestic capabilities.
This is increasingly a priority for government, as reflected in the streamlining of the Social Value Model and the anticipated new National Procurement Policy Statement next year.
Over the last 2 years, the CMA has undertaken work spanning the scale-up challenge, civil engineering, defence, cloud services and bid-rigging. While different in scope, each of these workstreams raised questions about the state’s power to influence the economy through procurement. We reported our findings to government and Parliament in September. The full report is well worth a read, but in short: there is an enormous opportunity for the UK to use its £400 billion of annual public procurement spending more strategically. But businesses tell us that processes are too costly, too fragmented, too complex, too short-termist and too risk averse.
We have heard how firms can face effectively the same procurement exercise multiple times across different parts of the public sector, increasing costs for suppliers while preventing government from effective use of its collective purchasing power. For example, one Blackpool based business told us we are reaching a point where capable SMEs will have to stop bidding altogether - they simply cannot justify the commercial outlay. And when that happens, they are unable to deliver local jobs and locally-driven growth.
And one UK-based AI startup told us that a successful pilot with a government department could have delivered around 20% growth for the business and created new regional jobs. In the end, the requirement was folded into an existing multi-million-pound contract held by a global consultancy firm.
We made 5 recommendations to government: stronger prioritisation and political support to take considered risks; better use of data; greater coordination (nationally and regionally); reduced barriers and streamlined processes; and finally, procurement approaches that work for emerging and advanced technologies.
I am pleased to say these recommendations have been well received, and we are now working with departments across government on how they can be put into practice.
The power of the country: resilience, sovereignty and shared prosperity
That takes me to the final layer: the power of the country. A sovereign and resilient nation needs the capacity to make meaningful choices about its critical infrastructure, economic dependencies and capabilities. And we are increasingly seeing very real demonstrations that access to technologies on which countries depend - including AI, cloud computing and satellite communications and business software - can in some circumstances be disrupted, or withdrawn at the touch of a button.
I should be clear about the CMA’s role here. Sovereignty does not appear in the Competition Act, and it is for government to decide what sovereignty means for the UK. Where we want greater control or domestic capability; where we are comfortable relying on others; what risks and trade-offs we are prepared to accept. The question for the CMA is whether, and how, competition and market shaping can help government achieve those goals.
Let me give 2 examples from our current work: cloud services and business software. These are not just products relied on by businesses - they now form part of the infrastructure on which the state itself depends. And, like all customers, government’s freedom to choose, and the degree of control it can exercise, will be constrained if markets have developed in ways that make alternatives hard to use, that make switching prohibitively difficult, or that have crowded out competition altogether.
Government accounts for up to 10% of UK demand for cloud infrastructure services, giving it considerable purchasing power. The CMA has been advising on how it can use that purchasing power in support of greater strategic autonomy and operational resilience for the UK. The competitive structure of the market matters to that ambition: whether government can switch suppliers or use more than one provider; whether it remains or becomes locked into a particular technology or ecosystem; and whether there is enough diversity of supply to provide genuine alternatives.
Elsewhere in the technology stack, the CMA recently proposed to designate Microsoft with Strategic Market Status in relation to its business software ecosystem - spanning operating systems, productivity software, identity and security, and increasingly AI, through tools like Copilot. As millions of people and organisations experienced last Friday, this software is deeply embedded across the UK economy.
But the issue is not the fact that Microsoft is widely used. It is whether the strength of the ecosystem makes it harder for organisations to switch, or to combine Microsoft products with those of other providers. That question becomes markedly more important as AI becomes ever more embedded in the software we already rely on.
Why does this matter to the power of the state, to its ability to provide public services? Because government should not find that its existing dependence on one software ecosystem determines the AI technologies it can use in future. Instead, it should be able to consciously choose the best tools as they emerge, to combine technologies from different providers, and to change course as technology evolves.
And government is not just another customer. As with cloud, its scale as a purchaser means its decisions can help shape the wider market. Procurement that supports interoperability, choice and genuine competition can create space for alternative providers to grow and innovate, widening options, and potentially also creating downward pressure on prices - not just for government but for businesses across the economy.
Conclusion
This may seem a long way from the power of people, where I began. But a country’s economic security, resilience and freedom of choice ultimately determine its ability to protect the opportunities and prosperity of its citizens.
Put another way, the power of the country and the power of the individual require the same thing: the ability to make meaningful choices, rather than having them made for you.
That is the thread running through everything I have spoken about today. People need agency over the choices that impact their lives. Workers need the freedom to shape their own careers. Businesses need the opportunity to enter, grow and challenge. Government needs the ability to shape markets in the public interest.
Competition and consumer protection cannot deliver all of that. But, as I said at Chatham House this time last year: they can help to build a country where opportunity and prosperity reach every corner. An opportunity to forge a fairer, more prosperous future for the UK.
That remains the prize. And the CMA has a critical part to play in achieving it.
Thank you.
Original article link: https://www.gov.uk/government/speeches/power-agency-and-good-growth


