Competition & Markets Authority
Win in Ping golf clubs case sends clear online retail signal
The Competition Appeal Tribunal has upheld the CMA’s decision that Ping Europe Ltd broke the law by banning the online sale of its golf clubs.
This landmark case sends an important signal that attempts by manufacturers to impose absolute bans on selling their products online are not permitted by law.
The Tribunal’s judgment dismissed an appeal by the golf club manufacturer against the CMA’s decision to fine it for breaching competition law and imposed a revised fine of £1.25 million.
In August 2017, the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) found that Ping had breached competition law by preventing 2 UK retailers from selling its golf clubs on their websites.
The Tribunal said it was of the “clear view” that “The potential impact of the ban on consumers and retailers is real and material. It significantly restricts consumers from accessing Ping golf club retailers outside their local area and from comparing prices and it significantly reduces the ability of, and incentives for, retailers to compete for business using the internet.”
Taking various factors into account, the Tribunal lowered the CMA’s original penalty by £200,000 to £1.25 million.
The CMA had accepted that Ping was pursuing a genuine commercial aim of promoting in-store custom fitting, but found that it could have achieved this through less restrictive means.
Following the judgment, Ping must allow retailers to sell online, though it may require them to meet certain conditions before doing so.
Ann Pope, Senior Director for Antitrust Enforcement, said:
This judgment sends a clear message to companies that try to stop customers shopping online for their products - they could be breaking the law. This matters because it removes a barrier to customers shopping around for more affordable goods.
The internet is an increasingly important sales channel and retailers’ ability to sell online, and reach as wide a customer base as possible, should not be unduly restricted by manufacturers.
Find out more about the CMA investigation on the case page.
Latest News from
Competition & Markets Authority
CMA provisionally clears media intelligence merger12/10/2018 12:20:00
The CMA has provisionally found that the proposed merger between Nielsen and Ebiquity does not raise competition concerns.
University laundry merger broken up by CMA12/10/2018 09:20:00
The CMA has decided that JLA must sell Washstation to preserve competition in the supply of managed laundry services to higher education providers.
SSE/Npower merger receives final clearance after consultation11/10/2018 09:20:00
The CMA has decided that the proposed merger between SSE Retail (SSE) and Npower can proceed, following a thorough review.
CMA launches immediate review of audit sector10/10/2018 09:20:00
The CMA has launched a detailed study of the audit sector to examine concerns that it is not working well for the economy or investors.
Algorithm research builds on work in digital markets09/10/2018 09:20:00
The CMA has published a study into pricing algorithms and whether they could be used to support illegal practices.
Lloyds issued with legal directions for PPI breaches05/10/2018 09:20:00
The CMA has taken action against Lloyds Banking Group (Lloyds) for serious breaches affecting thousands of PPI customers.
CMA to investigate ‘loyalty penalty’ super-complaint01/10/2018 09:20:00
The CMA recently (28 September 2018) received a super-complaint from Citizens Advice about long term customers overpaying for key services.
Addressing the challenges that vulnerable consumers face26/09/2018 16:15:00
Andrea Coscelli explores the different dimensions of vulnerability and what businesses and regulators can do to help vulnerable consumers.