Economic and Social Research Council
Women leaders, heralded as saviours during the financial crisis, are still measured by a male yardstick
Women leaders have been hailed as better equipped than men to resolve issues connected with the global financial crisis. Yet female stereotypes, amplified by the media, still undermine women in leadership positions, according to new research funded by the ESRC.
While media coverage of women leaders during the financial crisis has promoted a greater acceptability of 'feminine qualities', it is not enough to challenge the association of masculinity with leadership, according to the study, which was jointly authored by Professor Carole Elliott from the University of Roehampton and Dr Valerie Stead of Lancaster University Management School.
"Women are portrayed as embodying a different way of leading," says Professor Elliott. "They are seen as more ethical, cautious and collaborative than their male counterparts. The problem is that, traditionally, these traits are considered to be unsuited to leadership."
The study argues that the media have a contradictory approach to women leaders. Advantages attributed to women such as a tendency to be risk-averse are also described as disadvantageous – if women are risk-averse they cannot fulfil the leadership ideal of being a risk-taker. Similarly, while women may be seen as being successful in adopting masculine leadership characteristics, they are often portrayed as being unable to maintain them.
Since the financial crisis has been blamed on hubristic male leaders, the profile of women leaders has undoubtedly risen. Yet, while the media celebrate these women, they tend to focus on their female characteristics, photographing them in glamorous clothing and highlighting their looks and 'feminine' qualities. They also perpetuate gendered stereotypes, using emotional descriptors, such as 'feisty' or 'Iron Lady', the nickname attributed to Margaret Thatcher.
The study shows that this focus reduces the complex interactions involved in leadership to binary oppositions – male/female, masculine/feminine. Women leaders themselves can be complicit in this distortion by exploiting their 'womanliness' to gain press coverage.
Images often add a particular element of contradiction, according to the research. An article celebrating a woman's leadership qualities can be undermined by a glamour photograph portraying her in conventional female poses. Images can also imperceptibly diminish the authority of a female leader by her position relative to other figures in the picture.
"The media is a powerful player in the promotion or otherwise of gender equality worldwide and media representations of women have great impact on how women are viewed and view themselves," says Professor Elliott.
"A continued media focus on women's gender, not competence, ignores women's achievements as leaders and professionals, misrepresenting their ability, contribution and advancement. These misrepresentations undermine gender equality and social justice and perpetuate women professionals and leaders as 'out of place', constraining their progress.
"What emerges from our research is a pattern framed by a male leadership model that narrates the promise of women leaders but subjects them to an exoticisation process, which positions them as ‘other’ to the male norm."
Professor Elliott and Dr Stead's research also has important practical implications for organisations that sometimes rely on female leadership for short term projects 'to get things done' rather than recognising and rewarding women in the long term, including promotion to senior positions.
- Rachel Newby, University of Roehampton Press Office
- Victoria Tyrrell
Head of Communications, Lancaster University
Notes for editors
- 'Constructing women's leadership representation in the UK press during a time of financial crisis: Gender capitals and dialectical’ analyses the way in which leading women are represented both in the text and pictures of the Business sections of the Times, Guardian and Daily Mail during the global financial crisis of 2008 to 2012.
- The research has been critical in informing the ESRC-funded seminar series 'Gendered Media Mis(s)representations of Women Professionals and Leaders' - a collaboration between Roehampton, Lancaster and Bradford Universities
- The Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) is the UK’s largest funder of research on the social and economic questions facing us today. It supports the development and training of the UK’s future social scientists and also funds major studies that provide the infrastructure for research. ESRC-funded research informs policymakers and practitioners and helps make businesses, voluntary bodies and other organisations more effective. The ESRC also works collaboratively with six other UK research councils and Innovate UK to fund cross-disciplinary research and innovation addressing major societal challenges. The ESRC is an independent organisation, established by Royal Charter in 1965, and funded mainly by the Government.
Latest News from
Economic and Social Research Council
University-educated and men from the South are most likely to consider becoming an MP, new findings show18/01/2018 09:25:00
Gaps in class, income, gender and education are major factors in who runs for political office in Britain as well as the north-south divide, according to the first research of its kind in Britain.
Research finds best way to make decisions is to sleep on it15/01/2018 12:12:00
What is the best way to estimate risks or make important decisions at work or at home? A new paper from researchers in Nottingham and Amsterdam has concluded that it is usually better to adopt the old adage, 'sleep on it'.
New Migration Leadership Team will help academics speak to a broader community about migration10/01/2018 17:08:00
The complex topic of migration could be better understood if several academic disciplines worked together to explain it, according to the leader of a new research team, jointly funded by the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) and the Arts and Humanities Research Council (AHRC).
University of Sheffield to lead new Productivity Insights Network04/01/2018 16:15:00
The Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) is delighted to announce the establishment of the Productivity Insights Network from January 2018.