Depression, breakdowns and departments under pressure: the FDA finds the real impact of unsustainable workloads in the civil service
Excessive working hours culture is decreasing public sector productivity and negatively impacting the health and wellbeing of civil servants, an FDA study has found.
68% of respondents to the FDA’s Working Hours Survey believe their departments’ effectiveness “is negatively impacted by our workload and additional working hours”, while 82% believe working excess hours has adversely affected their wellbeing.
The FDA – the union for managers and professionals in the public sector – conducts this annual survey to monitor their members’ working hours, and to understand the impact of their workloads.
This year, 1,346 civil servants completed the survey. The findings describe a worrying trend of excessive working hours becoming the “new normal”, with 69% of respondents stating “my workload is set with no correlation to whether it is possible to complete in the time available, because it is assumed I will complete the work no matter what.”
74% believed working excessive hours is a problem in their department or agency, and 73% feel there is not enough staff in the organisation to complete its work.
The full report has been published and can now be downloaded.
The FDA is calling on the civil service to address these damning results.
FDA Assistant General Secretary Amy Leversidge yesterday said:
“Civil servants are devoted to their work and to serving the nation, but they cannot run on pure dedication. Our survey results show that these vital workers are under real pressure. The current status quo of ever-increasing workloads and stagnant pay cannot continue if the civil service is to deliver on the significant challenges ahead.
“The FDA are calling for Government departments to ensure civil servants have the resources they need to do their jobs. There needs to be a focus on recruitment and retention, so we have the right number of people to complete work and meet deadlines. Crucially, staff need to be allowed a life outside the office. Maximum hours do not equate to maximum efficiency: protecting their work life balance is not only the ethical thing to do, but the practical one as well.
“The Government is taking advantage of civil servants’ commitment to their work, and gaining many extra hours of work for free but this is a false economy. Increasing workloads are increasing the strain on civil servants who have been trusted with implementing Government policy at a time of national upheaval.
"The Government must demonstrate that they value these workers and ensure civil servants have enough time to do their jobs to the high standard the country expects.”
The survey results also included testimony from civil servants on the effect these excessive working hours are having on them. They yesterday said:
FDA members, Government Legal Department
"My blood pressure levels have significantly raised over the past 12 months during which the volume and intensity of my work has significantly increased and I have been prescribed blood pressure medication as a result, despite being only 41 and otherwise in good health."
FDA member, Home Office
"I'm suffering from depression and my marriage is strained due to unreasonable work life balance."
Keystone member, Department for Education
“I suffered a breakdown last year, was acutely ill with severe anxiety and depression and took sick leave for four months…I had worked as much as 65-80 hours to meet deadlines on pieces of work, which when our Minister changed were never taken forward. I finally cracked.”
FDA member, HMRC
“Stressed, pressurised colleagues trying to do too much in too little time leads to delays and errors. Policy is less well thought out, with more pitfalls for us to then identify and correct.”
Latest News from
FDA: Don't let Truss's dog-whistle tactics hide human impact of public sector exit pay cap10/04/2019 13:20:00
FDA General Secretary Dave Penman responded to the Government’s announcement of a cap on exit payments for public servants
FDA opposes Treasury halting public sector pension scheme valuations31/01/2019 15:37:00
Yesterday, Chief Secretary to the Treasury Liz Truss announced that the Government will be pausing one element of the valuations of public service pensions.
The FDA responds to ERG Vice Chairman Mark Francois's attack on civil servants24/01/2019 10:25:00
FDA General Secretary Dave Penman yesterday responded to comments Mark Francois made in a recent Conservative Home interview.
The FDA wins overtime for Government Legal Department21/01/2019 09:20:00
After almost two years of campaigning, the FDA has won overtime payment for Grade 6 and Grade 7 GLD staff.
Civil service turnover: Without fundamental reform, Government “will only repeat mistakes of the past”16/01/2019 14:10:00
FDA General Secretary Dave Penman responded to the Institute for Government’s report Moving on: the costs of high staff turnover in the civil service.
Alex Salmond investigation: FDA response09/01/2019 16:05:00
FDA General Secretary Dave Penman has responded to today’s announcement regarding the investigation into Alex Salmond.
Gender pay gap data "no early Christmas gift"21/12/2018 13:25:00
On 19 December, 18 Government departments published their gender pay gap data. Despite the timing, these findings are no early Christmas gift.
Scottish Government doesn’t truly value the work of FDA members13/12/2018 13:33:00
FDA National Officer Allan Sampson yesterday responded to the announcement of the Scottish Government’s public sector pay policy.
Standards Committee response: FDA raises concerns MPs may "kick Dame Laura's recommendations into the long grass"11/12/2018 13:25:00
FDA Assistant General Secretary Amy Leversidge yesterday responded to the House of Commons Committee on Standards initial proposals following the Dame Laura Cox report.