IFG - Government and Parliament relations deteriorating due to Brexit and minority government
A new paper from the Institute for Government looking at different areas of Parliament’s activity in the 2017-19 session finds that the relationship between Parliament and government has deteriorated in many areas, most recently in relation to prorogation.
Control of the parliamentary agenda has been a key battleground. The government used its control of parliamentary time to avoid scheduling any time for opposition-led debate over a five-month period between late 2018 and early 2019 – a key period in the Brexit process.
The report finds an increase in public engagement with Parliament, with more members of the public than ever before have been watching parliamentary action live on television and online: there has been a 237% increase in the average daily viewers of Parliamentlive.tv between 2017 and 2019, with viewing figures peaking at moments of key Brexit drama.
When it comes to the everyday work of Parliament since 2017, the report finds that:
- When Parliament is prorogued next week, the longest parliamentary session on modern record will come to an end. When the session ends, it will have lasted over 340 days – beating the previous 295-day record set in 2010/12.
- There has been a dramatic rise in security costs as MPs face unprecedented threats. In the 2017/18 financial year, a total of £4.2m was spent on providing additional security assistance to MPs – over £4m more than was spent annually only two years ago. Deep political divisions over Brexit have contributed to many of these threats, but they have also been fuelled by the rise of social media, with many MPs reporting experiences of persistent online abuse.
- Parliament has passed a comparable amount of primary legislation to most previous parliamentary sessions: 48 government bills have so far made it into law, with only six relating to Brexit.
- To try and limit defeats in the Commons, the government has kept its legislation beyond Brexit relatively narrow and uncontroversial – with bills on smart meters and circus animals – rather than attempts at major public service reform.
- Parliamentarians have had to scrutinise a large amount of secondary legislation to prepare the statute book for Brexit, with the burden of legislating falling unevenly between government departments and across the session.
- There has been a dramatic increase in the use of backbench procedures such as Urgent Questions (UQs) to hold ministers to account – MPs have demanded ministers come to the Commons to answer their UQs on a record 287 occasions during the session.
Joe Marshall, Researcher at the Institute for Government and report author, said:
“As the current session comes to an end, the prime minister’s decision to prorogue Parliament and attempts by MPs to prevent no deal have placed additional pressure on Parliament’s ways of working and its relationship with government – raising wider questions about the need to reform how parliamentary time is allocated and government activity is scrutinised.”
Dr Alice Lilly, Senior Researcher at the Institute for Government and report author, said:
“The politics of the session have been shaped by both Brexit and minority government. But Brexit hasn’t affected every aspect of parliamentary activity, and the fact that MPs have spent most of their time on other business is a good reminder that they have plenty else to be doing besides.”
Notes to editors
Latest News from
NIESR: Global growth to remain at 10-year low in 202013/02/2020 13:10:00
NIESR Press Release: Global growth to remain at 10-year low in 2020
NIESR Monthly GDP Tracker: UK Economy to grow again in 2020 Q113/02/2020 12:10:00
NIESR Monthly GDP Tracker - UK Economy to grow again in 2020 Q1
IEA - The decision to go ahead with HS2 is “highly unlikely to transform the North”13/02/2020 10:35:00
Dr Richard Wellings, the IEA’s Head of Transport responded to the news that the Government is set to approve the High Speed 2 (HS2) rail project
Govt response to Online Harms consultation threatens freedom of speech and innovation, says IEA expert13/02/2020 09:35:00
The IEA’s Head of Regulatory Affairs Victoria Hewson commented on the government’s initial response to the public consultation on the Online Harms White Paper
IEA - Government should be alert to possible unintended consequences of a “mansion tax”11/02/2020 12:35:00
The IEA’s Academic and Research Director Syed Kamall responded to reports that the Prime Minister is planning to impose a “mansion tax” on owners of expensive homes
Give GPs the right to NHS salaries in switch from system of independent contractors, says IPPR11/02/2020 11:35:00
Historic GP ‘partner model’ should be phased out in England to tackle workforce crisis, provide better care and ‘let doctors be doctors’
IFG - Former ministers reveal experiences of May and Cameron governments11/02/2020 10:35:00
Chris Grayling, David Lidington, Jeremy Hunt and James Brokenshire have given candid interviews about their time serving as ministers for former prime ministers David Cameron and Theresa May.
JRF - Break the grip of poverty to “truly level up” our uneven nation11/02/2020 09:35:00
Poverty’s grip on some parts of the UK, some families and among renters shows the scale of the challenge faced by the government in its attempts to “unite and level up” the UK following years of political turmoil around Brexit.